13 Old-School Casseroles You Hardly See On Dinner Tables In 2026
Is there anything more old-school homey than a casserole? These hearty baked dishes rose to prominence during the Great Depression, and it's easy to see why. They're simple to make with just a few affordable ingredients, plus they're comforting, filling, and a great way to feed a crowd. Throughout the middle of the 20th century, numerous regional casserole variations popped up all over the country and became staples at family dinner tables, church suppers, and potlucks. Today, casseroles may be considered culinary relics, but we reckon there are several vintage versions that deserve a comeback.
If you grew up before the 1990s, you probably remember more than a few meals featuring a bubbling casserole. Depending on where you grew up (and when), those dishes may have featured ingredients like ground beef, canned tuna, or even pineapple. Toppings may have ranged from bread crumbs to crushed potato chips and tater tots. And, of course, every old-school casserole needed something to make it creamy, such as canned soup, butter, cheese, or heavy cream. If that already has your mouth watering, here are a few old-school casseroles that are well worth a second look.
1. Turkey tetrazzini
Once the holiday feast is over, the question becomes what to do with all the leftover turkey. For over a century, turkey tetrazzini has been a go-to solution for many home cooks. The history of the dish is a little murky, but we do know that it appeared around the early 1900s and was named in honor of Luisa Tetrazzini, a popular opera singer of the time. Some say it was created in San Francisco and others say in New York City. Either way, it became wildly popular for its combination of tender turkey and mushrooms, springy noodles, creamy sauce, and cheesy crust.
Early versions of turkey tetrazzini typically featured diced poultry, sliced mushrooms, onions, and cooked spaghetti noodles doused in a sherry cream sauce, topped with Parmesan and bread crumbs, and baked until golden. Around the middle of the 20th century, many cooks started swapping out the cream sauce for canned cream of mushroom soup and putting interesting twists on the dish, like adding peas and broccoli. If you want to modernize it a bit, try this elevated chicken tetrazzini featuring fresh herbs, wild mushrooms, and a combination of melty cheeses.
2. John Wayne casserole
If you love Southwest flavors, then the John Wayne casserole will be right up your alley. This cheesy cowboy casserole is named after its creator, Hollywood legend John Wayne (aka "The Duke"). It first appeared in a 1979 cookbook titled "Cooking with Love from Cara and her Friends," which featured a collection of celebrities' favorite recipes. The author was a 10-year-old girl named Cara Connery who created the cookbook as a way to raise money for cancer research. John Wayne's contribution was a zesty casserole featuring ingredients like eggs, cheese, jalapeños, and tomatoes.
Although the original recipe was vegetarian, the dish has since evolved into a hearty, meaty creation. It typically starts with biscuit dough pressed into a casserole dish that then gets topped with taco-seasoned ground beef, sautéed onions and bell peppers, jalapeños, tomatoes, sour cream, Monterey Jack cheese, and a final ample layer of cheddar cheese. From there, the casserole goes into the oven and bakes until the cheese is brown and bubbling. Some cooks swap the sour cream for an egg-and-cream mixture and add extras like crunchy corn chips on top.
3. Pineapple casserole
Pineapple may seem like an odd ingredient to star in a casserole dish, but many folks from the South will tell you that pineapple casserole is simply irresistible. It's typically made with chunks of canned pineapple tossed with sugar, flour, and shredded cheddar cheese. The mixture goes into a casserole dish along with crushed crackers (usually Ritz) and a drizzle of butter, then it's baked until golden. The end result is a simple but flavorful dish that's both sweet and savory, and offers a mix of crunchy, soft, and gooey textures.
It's unclear who created the first cheesy pineapple casserole or when, but the dish has likely been around since the early 20th century, as that's when canned pineapple became more accessible to home cooks all over the country. Some speculate that it may have evolved from pineapple stuffing, a baked dish that features the fruit mixed with eggs, stale bread, sugar, and spices. The casserole really took off in the South, where it became a favorite at potlucks and holiday dinners. And while it might be considered old-fashioned today, there's nothing to say you can't modernize it with upgrades like crushed nuts, dried fruit, or crumbled bacon.
4. King Ranch casserole
For many Texans, King Ranch casserole is one of those old-school chicken dishes that brings back memories of Sunday dinners at their grandparents' house or church potlucks. Although recipes vary, it typically consists of tortillas topped with shredded chicken, grated cheese, tomatoes, onions, cream of mushroom soup, and cream of chicken soup. Some people also add bell peppers, jalapeños, poblanos, or Ro-Tel tomatoes with green chiles, and season with things like cumin and chili powder. As the casserole bakes, the cheese melds into the other ingredients, creating a creamy interior and a crispy crust on top.
This Tex-Mex casserole is named after the famous King Ranch, which is the largest ranch in Texas. However, no one is really sure why, because there are no records that the casserole was created there. It's also unclear when it was created, but we do know that it was already a favorite in Texas by the 1960s, and later spread to other states. The dish shares many similarities with Mexican dishes like enchiladas and chilaquiles, so there's a possibility that's what it was based on, but with ingredients readily available north of the border.
5. Chicken Divan
Chicken and broccoli may seem like a no-brainer casserole combination today, but in the 1940s, it was a relatively novel pairing. That was, until chef Anthony Lagasi combined the two with a creamy, cheesy sauce in a bubbling baked dish he served at the Hotel Chatham's Divan Parisien Restaurant in New York City. The dish came to be known as chicken Divan, and it was all the rage at restaurants and dinner parties throughout the decade and well into the 1960s. It also inspired many other dishes, like the equally retro Nixon chicken casserole.
A classic chicken Divan only requires a few ingredients: sliced poultry, broccoli, a creamy sauce like bechamel or sherry cream sauce, and Parmesan cheese. Everything gets popped in the oven and baked until piping hot. Some people use canned cream soup instead of making a cream sauce from scratch, and others add mayo or egg yolks to amp up the richness. Others also take the dish one step further and add crunchy toppings like crushed crackers or potato chips, breadcrumbs, or sliced almonds.
6. Johnny Marzetti casserole
The Johnny Marzetti casserole is a nostalgic Midwest dish that gives goulash vibes. Legend has it that an Italian immigrant named Teresa Marzetti created this meaty noodle casserole at her Columbus, Ohio, restaurant around 1896, and that she named it after her brother-in-law. However, this may not be entirely true, as there are no records of the dish being on the menu at any of Marzetti's restaurants. What's more likely is that variations of the dish began popping up in the mid-20th century, and at some point, someone added the name to the dish, and it stuck.
As with many casseroles, recipes for the Johnny Marzetti vary, but there are a few ingredients that many Midwesterners will tell you are non-negotiable. These include ground beef, cheese (often cheddar), pasta, and tomatoes. But beyond that, the dish is pretty customizable. You can use any type of pasta (although short noodles like macaroni work best) and your favorite melty cheese. Feel free to make it more hearty with vegetables like mushrooms, onions, and bell peppers or legumes like beans. And at the risk of angering any Midwestern purists, you can even swap out the beef for other proteins like pork, chicken, or turkey.
7. Chow mein casserole
As casseroles began exploding in popularity during the middle of the 20th century, home cooks started adding all sorts of ingredients to amp them up. One ingredient that many Midwesterners remember their parents using was chow mein. Canned La Choy noodles were a familiar pantry item in the 1950s and '60s, and their crisp texture made them a great addition to creamy, savory casseroles.
While many of the old-school dishes on this list have a few core ingredients that distinguish them from others, chow mein casseroles only have one constant, and that's those crispy fried noodles. Some vintage recipes suggest using ground beef, while others call for chicken. Celery, onions, and carrots are common add-ins, but other ingredients can range from water chestnuts to jalapeños. Canned soups usually go into the mix, too, like cream of chicken and chicken with rice. Even the noodles can be modified to taste, as you can mix them in with the other things so that they soften as the dish bakes, or add them as a crunchy topping.
8. Tamale pie
Tamale pie has a slightly misleading name, as it's neither a tamale nor a pie. It's actually a Mexican-inspired casserole that features chili topped with a cornmeal batter and baked until the top turns into golden cornbread. Its exact origins are lost to history, but we do know that the dish has been around since at least the early 1900s and that it was likely born somewhere in the Southwest. It was very popular from the '30s through to the '50s, and although it's since fallen slightly off the radar, it still has many fans today.
A good tamale pie starts with a flavorful base. Ground beef is usually the go-to meat, although some cooks also include chorizo or bacon. From there, you can add ingredients like onions, corn, beans, tomatoes, and jalapeños, as well as seasonings like chili powder and cumin. The mixture is often simmered with stock until thick and poured into a casserole dish or cast iron pan with generous lashings of shredded cheese. The cornmeal layer goes on top, and the whole thing is baked until it has a golden crust. Many people serve it with dollops of sour cream.
9. Tater tot hotdish
Ask a Minnesotan about their favorite childhood comfort foods, and there's a good chance tater tot hotdish will be at the top of the list. In fact, hotdish is Minnesota's most famous food, and it has a long history. The first recipe appeared in the "Grace Lutheran Ladies Aid Cookbook" in 1930, and it featured hamburger, tomato soup, frozen peas, and macaroni. Numerous variations would follow, and after the Ore-Ida company released tater tots in 1953, innovative (and some would argue genius) cooks began adding them as a crispy topping.
There's no set formula for a tater tot casserole, although there are a few things it should have. Old-school versions typically include a protein like ground beef, a creamy soup to bind it together (cream of mushroom is a classic), and tater tots. Frozen vegetables like green beans or corn often get tossed in, and some cooks add a dairy element for extra richness. The tater tots always go on top so that they get nice and crispy in the oven, and a sprinkling of cheese on top is also a nice touch.
10. Tennessee onions
Onions usually add flavor instead of starring on their own, but there's one old-fashioned cheesy Southern side where they play the main role. Tennessee onions are a casserole-style dish that features thick slices of sweet Vidalia onions topped with pats of butter and grated cheese, then baked until tender, melty, and golden. It works beautifully as a side, but you can also use it as a topping for burgers, steaks, or pork chops. It also makes for a great sandwich filling.
Many cooks will tell you that the only onions that will do for this dish are Vidalia onions. Hailing from Vidalia, Georgia, they have a sweet character with just a hint of bite, and that's what gives the dish its beautiful sweet and savory contrast. The onions get sliced into rings, tossed with herbs and seasonings like thyme and garlic salt, then layered into a casserole dish. Butter and shredded cheese (often cheddar and gouda) go on top, and some cooks add a bit of broth to the dish for extra flavor and to help the onions soften.
11. Tuna noodle casserole
It's hard to think of a dish that's easier and more economical to make than tuna noodle casserole. All you need is a can of tuna, a can of cream of mushroom soup, maybe frozen vegetables, and some cooked egg noodles. Throw them all together in a casserole dish, top the mixture with something crunchy like potato chips or breadcrumbs, toss it in the oven, and you have yourself a meal. That's what made this dish especially appealing for generations of working parents over the past century.
The exact origins of tuna noodle casserole are not entirely clear, but we know that the first printed recipes started to pop up on the West Coast in the early 1930s, and they featured tuna and noodles baked in a creamy sauce with a cheese topping. When the Campbell's Soup Company released its cream of mushroom soup in 1934, many cooks began using it in lieu of homemade sauce. By the 1950s, convenience foods were all the rage, and the tuna noodle casserole became a staple in many American homes. It may not be as popular today, but it's a pretty solid choice when you need something fast, filling, and easy.
12. Shipwreck casserole
Looking for a fun way to use up some of the odds and ends sitting in your fridge and pantry? Shipwreck casserole is a retro meal that features ingredients you probably already have, including potatoes, onions, ground beef, and canned tomatoes or soup. Some say it got its name from sailors salvaging whatever ingredients they could from a sinking ship. However, it's more likely that it simply refers to how messy the casserole looks (like a shipwreck). The origin is also unclear, but many believe that it dates back to the 1940s.
On their own, the ingredients for shipwreck casserole can be pretty bland, so you'll definitely want to add some seasoning like salt, pepper, garlic salt, chili powder, or cayenne pepper. You also have plenty of leeway to get creative with add-ins like fresh or frozen veggies, cheese, rice, or pasta. And if tomato soup isn't your thing, there's nothing to say you can't swap it out for something creamier or richer. The beauty of shipwreck casserole is that there's no single right way to make it, so you can easily adapt it to suit your tastes or use up whatever you have on hand.
13. Scalloped oysters
Oysters might not be the first thing that comes to mind when planning a Thanksgiving menu today, but they were once a popular choice for holiday meals. During the 1800s, scalloped oysters were common at many celebratory feasts, particularly along the East Coast. In fact, the dish even featured on the White House Thanksgiving dinner menu in 1887, when President Grover Cleveland and his family enjoyed it alongside roast turkey, parsnip fritters, and venison pastry.
Scalloped oysters are pretty simple to make, as all you need to do is layer a casserole dish with buttered cracker crumbs, oysters, and another layer of crumbs. Add salt and pepper, a dash of oyster liquor (the natural briny liquid in an oyster shell), and some cream, then bake for about 30 to 45 minutes. Some vintage recipes also call for add-ins like tomatoes or corn. And if you want something a bit more substantial, you can always turn the dish into oyster stuffing with ingredients like bread cubes, onions, celery, and fresh herbs.