Amplify Dinner With Steakhouse-Style Mushrooms That Taste Gourmet

Add Chowhound on Google:
Google Discover

When you're dining at a great steakhouse, the experience may center around a succulent cut of beef, but the classic sides typically on offer are also a big part of the allure. Among dishes such as creamed spinach and the wedge salad, one accompaniment stands above the rest for its deep umami savoriness and buttery richness: steakhouse mushrooms. Every steakhouse seems to have its own version, from Ruth's Chris' pan-roasted creminis to Charlie Palmer Steak's wild mushrooms (flash-seared trumpets at the New York City location), but you don't have to wait until you visit a steakhouse to enjoy this dish.

While you may not be able to cook a steak at home exactly the way it's done at Ruth's Chris and similar establishments, achieving restaurant-quality results with pan-sauteed mushrooms is a lot easier. They can be whipped up in a couple of minutes and only require a few ingredients. Besides mushrooms, which can be anything from cremini to shiitake to white button, depending on your preference, all it takes is aromatics and add-ins like minced garlic, chopped shallots, butter, a little olive oil, fresh herbs including rosemary, thyme, or parsley, plus broth and wine. Because it's a simple dish, there's plenty of room for adjustments, but a few tips can help you get the best results.

Making steakhouse mushrooms your own

You'll only need one pan to make steakhouse mushrooms at home. You're basically sauteing everything in butter and olive oil before adding the aromatics, broth, and wine, and letting it all reduce. One easy way you can play around with the ingredients a bit is by using beef broth instead of chicken broth. Each will give the dish a different flavor and color (darker and richer vs. milder and lighter).

You could also use red wine rather than white. The former, especially if you're going with something like a pinot noir, is going to give the dish a more robust, earthier flavor, while the latter will be a bit more delicate — and if you choose a variety like a chardonnay, it will complement the dish's butteriness. Either way, use a decent wine since it will affect the flavor. You can also forgo the wine and use a little bourbon.

Lastly, if you want to achieve that beautiful browning you get at the steakhouse, make sure your pan is hot, don't crowd it, and let the mushrooms get a good sear on one side before turning them over. Fresh herbs will offer a nice contrast compared to the crisped fungi, but save heat-sensitive varieties like parsley and tarragon for garnishing rather than cooking. Once you serve these shrooms with a nice steak at home, you might not even miss the chophouse.

Recommended