For Potato Salad People Will Ask About, Make It Amish Style
Potato salad is a go-to dish at barbecues and potlucks, but anyone who has sampled a few of them knows they're not all created equal. Of all the different versions of potato salad from around the world, one of the tastiest hails from Pennsylvania. If you're looking for a potato salad recipe that'll have people wondering what you did differently, you'll want to give the Amish-style version a try. It puts a sweet, tangy twist on classic potato salad, taking it from an ordinary side dish to something that'll keep people coming back for seconds — and the secret is all in the sugary, vinegary dressing.
You don't need to live in the heart of Amish country (like me) to enjoy Amish-style potato salad, and there's a good chance you already have most of the ingredients you'll need in your own kitchen. First, your potatoes — Yukon Golds are a great choice for any potato salad. Start by boiling peeled and cubed potatoes until they're fork-tender. You want them to be soft enough that you're able to bite into them easily, but not soft enough that they turn into a mashed potato mess as soon as you try to mix the salad together. While your potatoes are cooking, hard-boil some eggs, chop some celery and onions, and get to work on the dressing you'll use to take your potato salad from so-so to an Amish-style showstopper. Let's take a deeper look at what makes Amish potato salad stand out.
Tips and tricks for making Amish-style potato salad at home
Ready to give Amish-style potato salad a try at home? For a simple version of the dressing, you can whisk together some mayonnaise, yellow mustard, a bit of sugar, and some white or apple cider vinegar. You can also add a little horseradish for an extra kick. Another option is to make a cooked dressing, whisking eggs, sugar, vinegar, and mustard together in a saucepan until the mixture thickens and then letting it cool before dressing your salad. Taste as you go, and add more sugar or vinegar depending on your preferences.
There are a few general tried-and-true potato salad tricks that you can apply to the Amish version to make it uber-delicious. Try following Martha Stewart's trick of adding dressing to the potatoes while they're still warm to help the potatoes absorb the dressing. You can also try adding straight-up vinegar to your potatoes before adding the rest of the dressing to let the spuds soak in that tangy flavor. One more thing — if you're lucky enough to live near an Amish market, serve your potato salad with some freshly baked Amish bread, a piece of meatloaf, and, of course, a slice of sticky-sweet shoofly pie (if you know, you know).