The Absolute Best Holiday Pie At Cracker Barrel Isn't Pumpkin Or Apple
For many people, holiday meals aren't complete without pie. It's great if you're up for making your own fall-inspired pumpkin or sweet potato pie from scratch, but for others, ordering from Cracker Barrel is the way to go. Fans love the variety and the crusts, which taste homemade. Thankfully, our intrepid writer meticulously sampled slices of the current holiday pie offerings from the Southern comfort food chain and found a clear winner: Pecan.
This fall, Cracker Barrel is offering five different holiday pies for a limited time, including classics like pecan, apple streusel, and pumpkin. While our professional taster enjoyed most of them, pecan came out on top (with chocolate pecan pie a very close second).
Our results found that Cracker Barrel's version shines for its buttery, swavory crust and sturdy caramel base with a bit of an acidic fruit zing. The texture of the filling was the right mix of gooey without being cloying or dull, with plenty of pecans for crunch. Chopped, rather than whole, toasted nuts on top of the pie were the coup-de-gras. While not every online viewer agrees with our decision to rank the classic pecan pie No. 1 — the chocolate pecan pie tends to do really well — it's still highly praised.
In a way this makes sense: Cracker Barrel got its start in Lebanon, Tennessee, and according to a recent DoorDash holiday survey, pecan pie is the favorite Thanksgiving pie order in that state. It's a Southern delicacy, taking advantage of the indigenous nut that was cultivated first by Native Americans, then by late 19th century farmers in Louisiana and Georgia. Pecan pie, as we know it, appears in cookbooks around the beginning of the 20th century.
How to get Cracker Barrel's pecan pie during the holidays
It's worth noting that these holiday pies are only available between October 20 and December 24, 2026. The best way to secure a Cracker Barrel pecan pie is by showing up and ordering one at the restaurant or for takeaway (Cracker Barrel is open on Thanksgiving for dining in or last-minute dishes for home). There are almost 660 locations in 44 states, so chances are fairly good you have access. You can also reserve one for pickup via the Cracker Barrel app or online. If you live close enough to a restaurant, Cracker Barrel will deliver pies straight to your home (a minimum order may be required).
One option is to order the restaurant's Holiday Heat & Serve Meals, like the Thanksgiving Heat & Serve Feast — a complete, ready made holiday meal, which feeds eight to 10 people and includes both a pumpkin and a pecan pie. A similar Winter Holiday meal featuring ham will be available for pre-order and can be picked up between December 21st and 28th.
Alternatively you can order just the pie or even a slice. While prices may vary by location or region, our taster and others reported that a whole pecan pie runs $14.49 and individual slices cost $5.19 each. Even if it's just you ordering, a whole pie is a deal over slices, so make sure and store it properly to preserve maximum freshness.