Transform Vanilla Ice Cream With Any Mix-Ins Using One Simple Method
If you think your vanilla ice cream is a bit too vanilla, you can always jazz it up with the wide variety of mix-ins at your disposal, from M&M's to crushed Oreos. But just like a well-layered ice cream cake, you don't want mouthfuls of just ice cream or just filling — you want a perfect mix of both in each bite. Whether you have a carton of store-bought ice cream or a fresh batch of the homemade kind to zhuzh up, you'll want to take a tip from the cake strategy and use a layering technique.
Store-bought ice cream is understandably difficult to work with if you're mixing extra goodies into it, and if you are adding them to a homemade mixture in an ice cream maker, you can't control their distribution as the frozen dessert churns. That's why the layering method should be your go-to in both cases. If you're making ice cream at home, you'll want to scoop it out and spread it into a pan while it is still soft. Evenly layer your mix-ins (you can use a combination of your favorites or go with a single ingredient), then spread another layer of ice cream on top. When you're done, pop it into the freezer to set until you're ready to scoop it and serve it.
On the other hand, if you're working with store-bought ice cream, you can still achieve the same result, but you'll have to let it soften it first. Leaving it out on the counter for a few minutes until it is soft enough to scoop and spread will do the trick. From there, you'll want to follow the same technique that you would use with homemade ice cream.
Tips to take your new-and-improved vanilla ice cream to the next level
To give your mix-ins the best chance of an even distribution using the layering method, think small. Not small in flavor, just small in size. If you're using ingredients like nuts, pretzels, candy bars, or dried fruit pieces, make sure to chop them into little bits. You don't want to grind them into a powdery consistency — you'll lose the texture by doing that — but you do want them small enough to ensure they can be evenly spread out enough to get into every bite.
It's not hard to pair ingredients with vanilla, but you want to make your mix-ins work well together if you're using a combination of items. Caramel and nuts, for example, are an amazing flavor combo, and they both go great in ice cream. If you toast those nuts before you add them, you'll also get a stronger flavor and a crunchier texture. Cherries go great with mini chocolate chips and roasted peanuts for an ice cream sundae-style treat. You can also create your own candy bar flavors, like layering in sweetened shredded coconut, chopped almonds, and chocolate sauce for an Almond Joy-inspired batch.
If you want to absolutely guarantee the same amount of mix-ins with every single bite of ice cream, you can always make chocolate-covered ice cream bites that are rolled in your choice of mix-ins instead, either under the chocolate or over it. But while tasty chocolate bon bons are always a welcome treat, they can be a fair bit of work; layering your favorite ingredients into your ice cream is ultimately a much easier option.