Turn Off The Oven — Roasted Potatoes Are So Fluffy And Tender Cooked Like This
We already know the Crock-Pot is the secret to making baked potatoes for a crowd, but that's not the only thing it can do. For the longest time, home cooks believed these convenient, hands-off gadgets were really only good at making saucy meals, such as pulled pork, chicken stew, and spicy slow cooker beef chili, but with the right modifications, they can roast whole chickens and yield the aforementioned perfectly baked potatoes. It's also the perfect vessel for producing the fluffiest, most tender roasted potatoes of your life.
Disclaimer: if you prefer crispy, golden-brown cubes of roasted potato, this isn't the technique for you. Since Crock-Pots use low temperatures and slow cooking techniques confined within a small, moisture-rich chamber, it's impossible to produce the sizzly reaction required to create a crunchy crust. However, slow-cooker roasted potatoes are beautifully velvety and full of flavor, especially if you choose a nice, waxy potato, such as Yukon Golds. Russets work, too, but they'll be even softer and a little starchier.
As with all the best Crock-Pot recipes, the method here is extremely simple: cube the potatoes, coat in olive oil and seasonings, then dump into the slow cooker for about five hours on low or two hours on high. They should be nicely tender all the way through without falling apart, perfect for enjoying alongside whole roasted chicken lightly seasoned with cinnamon, oven-braised brisket, or a beautifully rendered pot roast.
Why slow-cooker roasted potatoes are the best
While there's nothing wrong with returning to your conventional oven when the craving for crispy potatoes strikes, Crock-Pot roasted potatoes may become a staple workhorse recipe in your kitchen because they're so simple. Though you need to plan ahead a bit to compensate for the longer cooking time, they take just a few minutes to prepare and turn out flavorful and tender nearly every time. You can also make them ahead and reheat them in the microwave, or give them a few minutes in the oven (this makes them crispy).
This is also the easiest way to make big batches of roasted potatoes if you have a big family, or are planning a gathering. Even a fairly small 4.5-quart slow cooker can make at least five servings of potatoes at a time, so a 6-, 8- or 10-quart Crock-Pot is definitely up to the challenge of making enough roasted potatoes to feed a holiday-sized crowd. You can even serve the potatoes right from the slow cooker by flipping the knob over to the "keep warm" function, which keeps your potatoes nice and toasty for up to three or four hours. You can also flavor these potatoes any way you like. Swap olive oil for melted butter, mix garlic powder into the salt and pepper, make them beautifully spicy with cayenne and paprika, or even give them a toss in some honey mustard.