Can You Use Dark Liquor To Make Jell-O Shots?

Since the 1980s, Jell-O or gelatin shots have been popular within the party scene. Moreover, the wobbly handhelds have a surprisingly deep history that reaches back to the late 1300s. The most popular way to make them is by utilizing vodka or another clear spirit, such as rum, as the alcoholic agent. But are Jell-O shots limited to clear liquor, or would a dark liquor be suitable as well? The short answer is yes; clear, light, and dark liquors can be used. In fact, just about anything can be made into a Jell-O shot. However, the trick is understanding how the alcohol's potency affects the gelatin's stability.

Traditionally, Jell-O shots involve a packet of your favorite Jell-O flavor, one cup of boiling water, half a cup of cold water, and a clear, neutral spirit like rum or vodka. These are 80-proof spirits and typically what are used to make gelatin shots. The same principle applies to dark liquors like whiskey and brandy of similar proof. However, it's worth mentioning that no matter what spirit is being used, a higher proof alcohol results in a more liquidy Jell-O shot, and thus, requires balancing out the booze to boiling water ratio. The ratio may also affect how long it takes for Jell-O shots to set in the fridge or freezer. Usually, this means using an equal 1:1 ratio respectively, but a higher alcohol content may require doubling the amount of water being used.

With your creative juices flowing and measurements out of the way, your next question may be what dark liquor would serve a Jell-O shot best. When it comes to flavor profiles, cocktail recipes can serve as a springboard for creating Jell-O shots. Jack and Coke gelatin shots are perfect for whiskey lovers and easy to make — just use unflavored gelatin so you can taste the soda, unless the goal is a Jack and Cherry Coke variation. In which case, use cherry flavored gelatin. Margarita recipes also transform the tequila classic nicely into Jell-O shot form, taking advantage of flavors such as lime, orange, or island pineapple. 

Admittedly, things could go from a fun preparation to messy cleanup. To that, some handy tools can avoid a sticky disaster while pouring Jell-O shots. Of course, some companies are already a step ahead with liquid dispensers, such as the Jellinator, which is a spring-loaded nozzle that delivers shot mixes with just a simple press of its tip. However, you can also use what's available in your own kitchen — any bowl or measuring cup with a spout will do. As a final pro tip, there's one step to never forget with homemade Jell-O shots: Spray the cups with a non-stick spray for easier removal, and use a muffin pan for transferring the shots in and out of the fridge.