12 Best Breads For Tomato Sandwiches With Triple The Flavor

Add Chowhound on Google:
Google Discover

Few things are easier to make and more comforting than a well-balanced, quality sandwich. Whether it's a classic Reuben, club sandwich, BLT, or French dip, something about a good sandwich just hits. Even the most simple of sandwiches, with just a few ingredients, are delicious, such as a classic grilled cheese or egg salad sandwich. Then there are sandwiches so basic it's hard to understand how they taste so good.

Consider the humble tomato sandwich, which is as simple as a sandwich can get. Two pieces of white bread with a tomato, a touch of mayonnaise, and salt and pepper is near perfection. If you're looking for something a touch different, one of the most important elements of a tomato sandwich is the bread. The two slices of bread you choose for your tomato sandwich have serious influence on the end result. The usual choice is white bread, which can get the job done, but there are plenty of other tasty bread choices out there. That's why we decided to run through some of the best bread options for when you're making a tomato sandwich. Some of these 12 breads are traditional, while others might surprise you, but all of them make your next tomato sandwich absolutely delicious.

Multigrain

Multigrain bread typically offers more fiber, protein, and less sugar than white bread. Flavor-wise, this bread leans toward an earthy, nutty profile that's similar to wheat bread but with a little more punch. Try toasting the bread, then adding the tomato — maybe a nice, hearty beefsteak — with a dab of mayonnaise to make a solid tomato sandwich.

Sourdough

If you like a thicker, heartier bread to pair with your tomato, look no further than sourdough. During the 2020 pandemic, it seemed like everyone was experimenting with sourdough bread and making their own versions of starters. Unless you're the DIY type, though, you can easily buy great sourdough at most grocery stores. The bread brings tanginess thanks to the acidity from the sourdough starter. The longer it ferments, the more sour it tastes. The thickness of this bread holds up well to most any spread or sauce, which lets you go beyond just mayonnaise. Consider a garlic aioli, creamy butter, or some type of herb-forward spread to complete your tomato sandwich.

Ciabatta

Ciabatta is another Italian bread, similar to a baguette or sourdough, that features a crispy crust and an airy, fluffy interior. This bread has a mild flavor, so it begs for a classic treatment to add more punch. Vine-ripe tomatoes, mozzarella or burrata cheese, fresh basil, and a light spread of olive oil or garlic butter should do the trick. You can easily grab a loaf of store-bought ciabatta from Trader Joe's, Walmart, Amazon, Kroger, and many other grocery stores.

Focaccia

Focaccia, when fresh, is one of the most delightful bread options you can ever have. Though it takes a little time to make at home, it's actually quite easy. However, you can also find focaccia in plenty of stores. With a light, airy texture and mild salty flavor, it's the perfect bread for a simple tomato sandwich, or take it to the next level with a caprese twist: mozzarella, tomato, and a nice spread of pesto gets the job done.

Buttermilk biscuits

Who said sandwiches have to be composed with sliced bread? We sure didn't — warm, soft buttermilk biscuits take tomato sandwiches to the next level with a Southern twist. In keeping with the breakfast theme, you could add a little bacon and lettuce for a BLT, or just stick with the sliced tomato and a soft butter spread on each slice of biscuit. This is a delicious option that you can build out even more if you like; maybe add a little cheddar cheese and sour cream to the mix? With biscuits done right, you have a savory, buttery flavor profile to carry the relative mildness of your tomato.

Martin's Potato Bread

Potato bread is one thing, but Martin's Potato Bread is pretty much the industry standard — even Shake Shack uses it. So, when it comes to making a tomato sandwich, this brand is another fantastic option. Don't mistake the flavor here, you don't really taste potato; it's more of a butter and sweet combination that stands out.

Baguette

Much like its sourdough cousin, a baguette is another thick, hearty vessel to hold all the ingredients of a tasty tomato sandwich. This is also a milder bread in flavor, so it's ideal as a blank canvas to add a few other ingredients, such as a slice of mozzarella or Gruyère, some fresh herbs, and a basil garlic butter. If in season, consider using heirloom tomatoes to star in this sandwich creation.

Garlic bread

Garlic, butter, and tomato are a popular pairing worthy of a classic pizza — or a delicious tomato sandwich. This is such a popular style of preparing bread that you know exactly what you're in for here with the flavor. While most tomato sandwiches call for a simple sliced raw tomato, consider roasting for this one, which releases all those delicious tomato juices that perfectly complement the garlic and creamy butter texture.

Rye

Rye is high in fiber and vitamin B, but that's not the only benefit — rye is quite tasty, bringing an earthy, nutty flavor that's similar to multigrain or wheat bread. We like our rye bread tomato sandwich with mayo, Dijon mustard, and sliced red onion. If you're in a cheesy mood, mild cheddar or provolone isn't a bad addition either.

Pumpernickel

Pumpernickel is a denser, darker version of rye bread. It's a naturally sweeter bread made from rye berries, and sometimes it includes brown sugar or molasses to add even more sweetness. Consider slightly toasting this bread to add a touch of crunch to the denseness. It can be served simply with just tomato and mayo, or up the flavor a bit by making an avocado spread to layer with the sliced tomato. All of these ingredients together add a bit of savoriness and acidity to the bread's naturally sweet flavor.

Shokupan

If you're feeling a little more adventurous, use Japanese-style shokupan bread, a milk bread that's soft, mildly sweet, and holds up well to the juiciness from the tomato. Try it with a Cherokee purple tomato, or an heirloom beefsteak tomato.

Parmesan-crusted bread

Using parmesan-crusted bread is a little more labor intensive than some of the other bread options because you need to create the parmesan toast on your own, though it's easy enough to make on the stovetop or broiled on a sheet pan in the oven. Freshly grated parmesan, a little olive oil or garlic butter, and a touch of pepper does the trick. Like with garlic bread, parmesan-crusted bread tomato sandwiches deliver classic Italian flavors. All of these flavors together might remind you of a simple, traditional pizza.

Recommended