Make Any Batch Of Brownies Lunch Lady-Style With A Simple Finishing Touch

Add Chowhound on Google:
Google Discover

Despite some variation among regions, there are certain school lunch staples familiar to almost every person who's ever attended public school in the United States. These range from the infamous French bread pizza and oddly delicious grilled cheese to vanilla pudding in little paper cups and — everyone's favorite — lunch lady brownies. The moniker for these deliciously chewy treats is tied to their origins, as most of us enjoyed them for the first time in school.

Luckily, it's fairly easy to infuse pretty much any boxed mix or easy one-bowl recipe for brownies with childhood nostalgia simply by coating a finished tray of brownies in a layer of fudgy chocolate frosting. That thin layer of sugary frosting with a slightly dried, crackly top was the main difference between the iconic lunch lady brownie and every other kind. You don't even need to make the frosting from scratch, as the sweet canned stuff from the grocery store has the perfect texture and flavor.

The key to getting these brownies right is twofold: letting the brownies cool properly and whipping your frosting. Hot brownies will only melt the frosting and cause it to become a runny mess, while fully cooled brownies offer a stable base. Whipping the canned frosting aerates it and makes it silky and easier to spread evenly across the brownies' surface. Keep the layer of frosting fairly thin for authenticity, or pile it high the way you always wanted the lunch ladies to do throughout your entire childhood.

Lots of different ways to elevate lunch lady brownies

Though the frosting is the most important part of a good batch of lunch lady brownies, a truly authentic batch will also be soft and slightly cakey. While it's easy enough to find good recipes for this texture online, you can achieve a chewy, moist texture in your brownies simply by adding mini marshmallows. Melting and mixing them into the batter adds gelatin, which makes the finished brownies softer and chewier, in addition to adding a lovely dash of sugary sweetness that deepens the nostalgia factor.

Additionally, if you don't have any canned frosting on hand, or simply don't love the stuff, it's fairly easy to make a delicious frosting from just three household ingredients: instant pudding mix, milk, and whipped topping. This frosting may be a bit fluffier and lighter than the stuff you remember, but it's an easy alternative. You can also certainly make your own classic fudgy frosting from butter, cocoa powder, and powdered sugar, if you prefer.

Some fun touches to add to the finished product include colorful, candy-coated chocolate chips or crushed walnuts. Up the ante even more by serving these up alongside frozen French bread pizza or walking tacos and a glass of milk. Or indulge your inner child by topping these cafeteria-style treats with ice cream while watching your favorite childhood movie.

Recommended