7 Vintage Egg Dishes We Wish Would Make A Comeback
There are many egg dishes that once graced tables across the country but have since fallen out of popularity over the years for various reasons. From quick and simple bakes to more extravagant deep-fried versions and even a dish that incorporates corn flakes, these vintage egg dishes have slowly been forgotten through time.
We dug through history to find the classics that once provided quick snacks and filling meals for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Some dishes were inspired from countries around the world, while others are home-grown, but they all have a few things in common: They not only show the versatility of this protein, but also unique ways people once enjoyed them daily.
From simple, comfort classics to whimsical takes on the protein, here are seven vintage egg dishes we wish would make a comeback on tables today. Which ones would you love to see again?
1. Dutch Baked Eggs
Dutch Baked Eggs just might become your new brunch favorite. Though the recipe was featured in 1940s cookbooks, by the 1970s, it appeared to die out. This was possibly because American descendants of Dutch immigrants had become more assimilated by then, and as a result, recipes like Dutch Baked Eggs became less popular. These days, we know there are health benefits to reverting to protein-packed recipes like these, so it may be worth reconsidering. For example, incorporating fish into your breakfast is said to help you tackle sugar cravings.
You start this dish by chopping hard-boiled eggs. Mix them with melted butter, parsley, chervil, and shrimp. Then, you'll add mustard powder, cream or evaporated milk, and salt and pepper. Next, you'll grate cheese and butter over your mix, and throw the whole thing in the oven for 10 minutes at 400 degrees Fahrenheit.
Chervil, by the way, is also known as French parsley. More power to you if you have time to track it down, but we won't judge if you decide to use just parsley, rather than adding its cousin to this dish. And if the idea of shrimp and boiled eggs still feels odd to you, ask yourself if you have the same prejudice against smoked salmon and poached eggs!
2. Pickled Eggs
When preservation was a necessity rather than a preference, pickling eggs was a no-brainer. Before Prohibition, pickled eggs were a ubiquitous bar snack. Culinary historian Linda Pelaccio told Punch Magazine: "The city health department pretty much wiped out a lot of the bar food from that era." When Prohibition ended, the food culture in bars had moved on. Pickled eggs have (mostly) continued to lose favor with the American audience since then.
A basic pickled eggs recipe starts with two cups of vinegar, two tablespoons of sugar, a dash of salt, and your choice of spices. Put your eggs (boiled and peeled) in a jar and pour the mixture over them. Then you'll seal the jar and let it sit for at least two days. A popular variation requires boiling beets and adding the juice to your brine for eggs with a distinct purplish-hue. One Reddit user remarked about a 1936 recipe from the "Pennsylvania Dutch Cook Book:" "I remember being so appalled at my pap's giant jar of pickled eggs and beets, but man are they good in a salad."
Consuming pickled foods is associated with health benefits like improved digestion, thanks to the helpful bacteria in these dishes. Because of this, we think these eggs are worth revisiting. Pickled eggs are also a quick and filling snack. What's not to love?
3. Chicken Livers and Eggs
This recipe calls for four eggs and ½ a pound of chicken liver. The liver and eggs are boiled with leeks, ginger, sherry, soy sauce, sesame oil, and sugar. Featured in recipe books from the '40s to the '70s, other versions of this dish used ingredients like cream and butter rather than ginger and soy sauce.
Recipes like this have become more rare in the United States, as fewer people eat organ meat these days. Yet, while this may feel like a stretch for (modern) Western palates, there are so many reasons to re-embrace, nose-to-tail, or rather, foot-to-beak cooking. In addition to the possibility of discovering a new favorite dish, you'll also be helping to reduce food waste. "It's going to end up in a landfill or need to be shipped, which also requires greenhouse gases. It's a sustainable choice to consume organ meats," Jordan Kraft Lambert, director of agricultural innovation at Colorado State University, told Rocky Mountain PBS.
For the sake of sustainability, it's worth giving this quirky dish a chance to come back. Try a few vintage recipes and see which way you prefer your liver.
4. Schwalbennester
This East German dish ("Swallow's Nest" in English) was popular in the post-World War II era. The Schwalbennester was an inventive way to stretch a minimal amount of meat. However, after the fall of the Berlin Wall, East Germans had access to a wider variety of foods, and the food of this era acquired a negative reputation.
While Schwalbennester can be made with pork or veal, some versions featured ham and beef shank. Creatively crafted during a time when food resources were limited, this dish was often eaten during family gatherings. The meat is wrapped around a boiled egg, coated in flour, and sautéed with onions. Then, they are brought to a boil with broth and sour cream. Managing to complete the dish without your swallow's nest falling apart is surely an accomplishment.
Whether we're talking about East Germans in the post-World War II era, or American housewives during the Great Depression, we know these past generations were no strangers to hardship. Their craftiness can be very helpful to anyone looking to stretch their dollar as grocery prices increase in our challenging modern era, so use this dish as inspiration!
5. Creamed Eggs
The base recipe for creamed eggs only requires two ingredients: hard-boiled eggs and white sauce (typically, a Béchamel sauce). Also known as Goldenrod eggs, this dish had many associated recipes that appeared in cookbooks from the 1940s and '50s. But these days, it seems to have been almost completely forgotten about.
One reason for this dish falling out of popularity may have been the arduous process of making its Béchamel sauce, which involves a somewhat complicated process that requires you to mix ingredients like milk, butter, and flour together, then slowly thicken them as sauce on the stovetop. These days, a recipe like this would hardly seem worth the effort when many of us are too busy to even sit at the dinner table.
One Reddit user mentioned this being an after-Easter treat in their family. Another Redditor commented: "Creamed eggs (with bacon) over toast was a staple growing up. Awesome to see it in a proper recipe book!" This recipe is a brilliant way to use up boiled eggs after the egg hunt, and likely to become a fond memory for younger family members. Why not consider making it one of your family traditions?
6. Cheese Scotch Eggs
A Scotch egg is essentially a large meatball with a boiled egg in the middle. Though the outer layer is often made with minced meat, if you're also intrigued by the idea of a meat-less Scotch egg, you're in luck here. For this vintage egg recipe of cheese Scotch eggs, simply replace minced meat with a cup and a half of grated cheddar cheese to make this 1967 recipe. Then, coat boiled eggs in a mixture of flour, cheese, Worcestershire sauce, milk, and cayenne. Roll them in breadcrumbs, and fry for two minutes.
Popular in the early 20th century, by the 1970s, Scotch eggs were suffering from an association with being a cheap, low class food. The case for this dish's revival is in its versatility. Soft-boiled eggs, mashed potatoes, and quail eggs are just a few ways to change up the standard Scotch egg recipe.
Like many of the recipes on this list, the nostalgia factor is a major determinant of whether you'll enjoy the recipe. However, these are a great option to bring to the potluck, and what's not to like about fried eggs and cheese?
7. Crispy Baked Eggs
Featuring bacon fat, corn flakes, and eggs, this dish's name doesn't do justice to its inventiveness. Working mothers in the '50s popularized the dish, which only requires four ingredients and five minutes of prep time. These days most of us find ourselves under a similar time crunch, even if we're not working mothers.
All you have to do is coat your cornflakes in bacon fat (or butter) before distributing them into a greased cupcake pan. You'll break one egg over each cup, season with salt and pepper, and bake for 15-20 minutes. Practice using your free will on a Monday morning by combining your eggs and cereal. If it's cosigned by 1950s moms, then surely it's a legit breakfast option, right?
It's hard to say why this dish lost popularity, but it was perhaps a side effect of the more health-conscious 1980s. Hopefully, the next era of food history will be a more balanced one, featuring healthy choices and fun indulgences. As we become more aware of food trends, we don't have to follow them. Dubai chocolate, protein in places it doesn't belong, and truffle-infused snacks have all come and will likely soon go. Meanwhile, much like in fashion, we can always look to the past to retrieve some favorites from yesteryear. When that happens, your cornflakes and eggs will remain, faithfully waiting for you to try this recipe.