After searching on Chowhound, Google and other forums, I have still come up short!
What we're searching for, is a bar in the GTA that has a promotion similar to Bottlescrew Bill's in Calgary seen here:
The promotion is called "Around the World in 80 Beers" and it involves having all eighty beers on the list and once it's all said and done, you get your name engraved on a plaque on the wall and other novelties. I've also seen this done at a bar in the U.S and so we are searching for a similar themed spot in Toronto or surrounding areas.
If anyone has a suggestion, we'd really appreciate it!