My dad is celebrating his 60th birthday with 4 family members next month and is an adventurous eater (as are the rest of us). We'd like something around $100 per person (not including wine, tax or tip).
The most important element (after excellent food and service) is that the restaurant not be too loud as he is a bit sensitive and it might destroy the meal (and we're not willing to risk it!).
I'm thinking of Custom House (would it be 'quiet' there?) but I am definitely open to other suggestions (as we are not from Chicago).