+
General Discussion

Shiitake mushrooms look and smell fine, taste SOUR??

tinyfish | Sep 15, 201412:18 PM     2

I use Shiitakes a lot and have never come across this before yesterday. I had bought two packets of particularly large Shiitakes (in fact, I'd never seen them this big before either). After the first packet tasted funny yesterday (acidic, as if they'd been soaked in lemon juice) I contacted the customer services dept of a Shiitake grower today who assures me this is not something that would happen naturally as a result of a mushroom growing bigger (any size Shiitake should taste the same). I just cooked the second packet and paid particular attention to pre-cooking taste and smell and texture and noticed out of the ordinary, but once again they tasted so sour that I did not want to eat them, particularly so around the edges. I cannot find anything about this online. Has anyone here experienced this before? Is it a different variety of Shiitake perhaps (thought surely the grower would have known about this) or were they off somehow?

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

Invite a friend to chime in on this discussion.

Email a Friend

More from Chowhound

9 Free Online Cooking Classes We Love
Food News

9 Free Online Cooking Classes We Love

by David Klein | Online cooking classes are a great way to learn new skills, but you don't necessarily have to dish...

12 Coffee Products You Never Knew You Needed
Shop

12 Coffee Products You Never Knew You Needed

by Emily Murawski | Does social distancing have you missing Starbucks—and frantically Googling how to make good coffee...

Try This Chef's Neat Trick for Storing Asparagus
Guides

Try This Chef's Neat Trick for Storing Asparagus

by David Klein | ‘Tis the season for asparagus. The reedy green veggie offers a satisfying textural combination of...

Where to Find Food Assistance During COVID-19
Food Trends

Where to Find Food Assistance During COVID-19

by David Watsky | The continued spread of coronavirus and the shutdown of non-essential business has had devastating...

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.