A long, long time ago I posted a query here looking to find a butcher - anywhere - that was a true butcher. Someone who would/could actually order and cut meats to custom order. I was frustrated by all the pseudo butchers at supermarkets who knew less than I did about most meats.
Someone way back then recommended Crisfields on Purchase Street in Rye. I remember looking for it - didn't find it and didn't look again. Lately I've been looking for good, whole brisket to smoke and couldn't find anywhere that would sell me a whole brisket. They only sell the flat of the brisket. I tried every supermarket, "meat market", whole foods, costco, Sam's etc. and no luck. I decided to try and find Crisfields' again and am glad I did.
They are a true old butcher shop. Knowledgeable and friendly. At first I thought they would be inordinantly expensive, but they weren't. While very slightly more than a supermarket, they are still far less than Whole Foods (I saw aged porterhouse there for around $10/pound).
Not only did the guy say he could order brisket for me, he told me to give him a few days in advance and they'd hang it for me for a few days to age a bit. No extra charge. And the price is $2.99. Not as cheap as you can find in some parts of the county, but only $.50 more than costco sells its brisket flats. Awesome.
Anyhow, if you are looking for it, don't go by Yahoo/Google Maps. It will point you to the wrong Purchase street. This place is in downtown Rye. Go to Purchase Street, find #61, then go behind the building in the parking lot and you'll see it.
Thanks to whoever it was way back then who recommended the place. Very cool.
Crisfields Prime Meats
61 Purchase St.
Rye, N.Y. 10580