Buffalo Grille is one I have to put out there. Why on earth do people pay over $10 for eggs and a side of bacon? The food is acceptable but certainly not worthy of its praise and price.
I know people will say that if price is my argument for it being overrated then I am wrong. I would counter be saying that a place like BG is what chowhounding isn't about. Are goal should be to let chowhounds know about the little neigborhood joints or dive's that are great, that a foodie wouldn't go to because it isn't where all the people in town are hanging out.