The last time we were in Mystic (2 years ago) we tried the fairly new Olio and really enjoyed it. We will be in Mystic for New Year's and are trying to plan our weekend. We already know we will be at Floodtide's on Friday (we would rather do their regular menu than the New Year's menu) and we may go to Go Fish on our last night. For New Year's itself we were thinking of Olio, but Bravo Bravo (same owners I believe) has been recommended several times. But, I have read very mixed reviews on several sites. Can anyone offer some advice?
By the way, I know Go Fish isn't exactly high dining, but we went there for the first time after a long drive up on a Friday night (it was one of only a few places still open for seating) and it kind of grew on us. It is a great place to unwind, have a good martini, and decent meal.