I haven't seen much (any?) writeup on Milk & Cookies on Bedford St. on this board. It's a shame because they are awesome. I'm totally not a shill; I work nearby and have walked by for a while and decided to go in. I had a chocolate mint chip and it was fantastic - just the right amount of softness without falling apart. So. Good. I also sampled one of their brownies - also delightful. I'll definitely be back!