In the Tulsa OK area you can get unpasteurized cheese (I like the white cheddar best) at Swan Brothers Dairy near Claremore. If you are visiting Oklahoma State at Stillwater, a short drive south to the Idle Knot Dairy near Ripley will yield several goat-milk cheeses, including a goat-milk cheddar and some Spanish types. I haven't tasted them all, but I'm trying (they're also at Crescent Market and a few at The Earth in OKC). The last I heard, regulators will not allow him to mix cow & goat milk and that is wildly frustrating since obviously it limits the cheeses he can produce. If you stop by, he'll tell you ALL about it, trust me.
SWAN BROTHERS DAIRY
938 E. 5th Claremore, OK 74017-9104 (918) 341-2298, FAX: (918) 341-2298 Products: Grade A Raw Milk (Whole, Skim, 2%), Cheese, Fresh Whipping Cream
IDLE KNOT FARM DAIRY Rt. 1, Box 2340
Ripley, OK 74062-9801 (918) 372-4564, FAX:(918) 372-4564 Brand Name: Idle Knot
Products: Goat Cheese, Goat Summer Sausage