Le Bisto in Hewitt NJ which I believe may be part of West Milford. My in-laws took the whole family (12 of us) for an early dinner on Saturday. It was fantastic. Service was impeccable and w lots of personality. Extras (No charge) included delicious bruschetta at the beginning of the meal and fresh cut oranges over ice which were the juiciest, tastiest I've had this season. In adddition to the large menu there were at least half dozen appetizer and half dozen entree specials. Menu was italian and all dinners served w salad and side of pasta. Examples of what we had included steak au poivre, talapia served picatta style w lemon and capers, veal saltimboca, chicken stuffed w asparagus, cheese ect.. Had grilled portabello, calamari and the best crab cakes as appetizers. The bill for 12 only $270 plus tip.
Awesome...Can't wait to go back. Too bad I live so far away.