New! Chowhound Cities: Satisfy your curiosity and your palate. Explore Cities
Home Cooking 10

WHAT did I do to this frosting?

nooodles | Jul 22, 2005 01:51 PM

Linked below is a custard/buttercream recipe posted by krissywatts awhile back. It's a great recipe, but what on earth did I do to it?

I made the frosting last night, following the instructions precisely. Then, I added half a teaspoon of Boyijian lemon oil, and the juice of half a lime. I think that's where I went wrong.

The frosting was light, fluffy, and smooth when I went to bed. I was sooo happy with it! This morning, it had set in the fridge, and still looked okay. But when it came back up to room temperature, it began to sweat a little (it's NOT hot in my apartment, 70 tops). I stirred it, and I could see that it had started to curdle ever so slightly. Since it wasn't too bad, I went ahead and frosted a cooled cake.

It looks gawdawful. The curdling is really obvious now that the frosting is spread on the cake, and ths frosting softened up really quickly and started sliding everywhere. I threw it back in the fridge, and now it's a little more stable but still ugly. Edible, but really really ugly.

Did the lime juice work its magic overnight? If it did, how do I go about making a lemon or limed flavored frosting?

Finally, a non-disaster related question for krissywatts: is this frosting supposed to set up hard enough to pipe, or do you think it's too soft for that?

Thanks to all for advice!


Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound