I was there this weekend for the first time and it wasn't as bad as some people say it is (ie. Sietsema). They didn't have the soft shell crab sandwich on the menu as the waitress said the crabs they received were too small. I had the grilled salmon and it was great. Also, they have the raw platter, but it seems to me that the size of the platter drowns out the small size of the contents.
On a side note, has anyone noticed any especially extra curricular activities that go on at the bars? There was one couple where the girl was obviously fawning over the guy. With a lot of grinding and certain things perking out, it's hard to have a decent meal while this is going on (this was late lunch).