Our wedding anniversary will be celebrated on Sat May 31. If DH were to choose, we would probably walk to The Top Steakhouse and then to Graeter's, Mozart's or Johnson's for dessert. He is very much Mr. Meat & Potatoes and massive quanitites of food (he is 6'3). He worries about nouvelle cuisine portions and will not complain out loud that he is still hungry but gets angry when we spend $$$$ on dinner and he has to make a sandwich when we get home. No vegetarian, not much diversity of palate, stick to the familiary kind of guy. He is allergic to fish/seafood (iodine), peppers and sweet potatoes and doesn't eat cooked vegetables.
Some places that did not work for him - La Tavola (we had BAD service), Hyde Park Grille (overcooked steak, rude service), M (didn't get enough to eat), Worthington Inn (dinner didn't agree with him), Basi Italia (I love this place, but he had full dinner after dinner(!). No Dragonfly Neo V for him!
So, here are some positives - Barcelona (love their patio if its a nice night), Handke's (he is OK with a steak there), The Refectory, G Michael's, Lindey's (we just went there), Trattoria Roma (not fancy enough for anniversary)
Any suggestions? Thanks!