My wife and I will be making our FIRST EVER visit to New York at the end of May. We will be staying at the Milford Plaza Hotel and will be within walking distance of Times Square. We will only be in town for three days and will be on a pretty tight budget. I have read numerous posts and visited forums pertaining to cheap eats in the area, but thought it might be beneficial to start my own (it gets really hard to remember and/or sort all of the posts out after a while). We prefer to eat at places we've never eaten at before (we live in Alabama and have eaten at most of the big name food chains), but we want to shy away from Thai, Indian, or any other spicy-type food. Whether it's in Times Square or in the surrounding area, do you have any suggestions for low-budget dining? Breakfast, lunch, dinner ... your suggestions are welcome. We're also open to suggestions for things we MUST do while in the area. Thanks!