Brand new Chowhound here...
In a few weeks, my girlfriend and I will be celebrating our 3 year anniversary. On the same day (a saturday afternoon) we have tickets to the Yankee/Red Sox game. We're season ticket holders who live on Long Island and commute into the Bronx via Manhattan by LIRR/subway to see the games.
I'm looking for a nice place to go to dinner that has a really casual setting (we will most likely be in shorts and Yankee gear). We're fairly adventurous eaters and are more concerned with good food rather than good atmosphere (although a decent atmosphere would be nice if possible).
I appreciate any and all help that I can get, forgive me if I don't respond too often, I can only check the board so many times at work.