Oh what a dissapointment. I read about this place in the Village Voice recently and was discussing with a co-worker, who raved. The name sounded vaguely familiar and there is indeed one in Rockville Centre, so we got to-go. Was it an off day, an off time? The Roast Beef for which they are famous was ok, but on a soggy bun, way too soggy. The fries were average but undercooked. My friend ordered a Caesar Salad, which turned out to be lettuce, Newmans Own Caesar dressing packet, and a packet of croutons, I kid you not. Mashed Potatoes that she says were homemade in Brooklyn were of the instant variety here. The only thing that was decent was the Onion Rings. It was voted by the Village Voice as the Best restaurant in Mill Basin !!! ???