Follow us:

Home Cooking 12

Bread noob needs help, dense bread

AramS | Jan 30, 201207:09 PM

Hi, I am a bread baking newbie. I'm learning from Reinhart's Crust and Crumb. My problem is too-dense bread.

I made the first French bread recipe a number of times. Details that might matter: I followed the recipe to the letter (used the right flours and measured by weight, used instant yeast, malt powder, etc, water at the correct temperature, etc.)

I used a stand mixer (Kitchenaid Artisan) to knead the first batches of loaves, and did the last 2 by hand. Baked the first few as he describes (oven + water spray + tray of water), followed his time and temperature schedule, second rise overnight in fridge. Got very dense bread. Also, the crust rapidly became soft once I took it out of the oven. Next few I tried a dutch oven at 450, solved the crust problem but of course as dense as ever. I wanted to stick with one recipe to really learn it, but just to see, I made a pugliese (which uses a pre ferment). Super dense as well.

Internet searches said too much flour, not enough water (maybe) so last batch, I added a little water until dough was a little sticky/tacky. No help. By the way, I don't think I ever got a really good windowpane. I did knead for a varous amounts of time, checked that dough was in 77-80 deg range, windowpanes were never very -- windowpaney. (They tore a lot less when I was done though!)

My oven is a piece of crap (but I did check its temp with a thermometer) if that matters.

Suggestions? I realize there are other recipes and ways to bake, but I would like to nail this French bread recipe rather than give up and try another one.

Sorry about the long post. All help welcome.

First post!

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

Recommended from Chowhound

Catch up on the latest activity across all community discussions.
View latest discussions