I'm looking for a romantic restaurant to celebrate my boyfriend's birthday. Excellent food is a must, and romantic ambience/decor too, but not over the top or stuffy. He brought me to Jean-Georges for my birthday which was exquisite. I'm currently deciding between One If By Land, Blue Hill and Chanterelle. Does anyone have any thoughts as to which of the 3 might be best? I would choose OIBL by virtue of the fact it seems most romantic and ideal for special occasions, but is the food quality of high standard? Any comments are appreciated. And please recommend other restaurants as well. Thanks!!!