Sorry this is so last minute, but we just decided to take a ride over to Block Island from Montauk tomorrow, just for the day. I checked their Chamber of Commerce website to get an idea of where to eat lunch, I'd heard of the more expensive places from friends who have been over, but I'm looking for something more pub-like, with good seafood. The ones that sounded good were Finn's and Deadeye Dick's. Someone had posted earlier this summer and didn't mention either of these. Any suggestions?