Restaurants & Bars

Boston Area

Blackfin Chop House & Raw Bar


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Restaurants & Bars 4

Blackfin Chop House & Raw Bar

MC Slim JB | Mar 26, 2004 12:07 AM

Stopped in here for a late meal on a whim, having read that it's a significant step down in price from Ambrosia, the former occupant of this space (same chef/owner). Bad news: it's just as expensive as Ambrosia, with a similarly high-priced wine list: few options under $30 and most wines $60 and up.

Can't say I much like the new look: it's very dark, with almost black walls, a lot of polished wood, and hokey gold-plated fishing gear as room accents. Salads and apps mostly run in the low teens. The market-priced steaks are all around $30, which may be a bargain for a 16-oz three-week-aged prime sirloin, but we didn't order one: none of us could imagine tackling a pound of beef at 10 o'clock at night. A sashimi dish for two at the next table looked very pretty: for $30, one hopes it was very good.

Portions are massive, a big change from the sensible, even smallish portions of Ambrosia, which I frankly prefer. My monkfish loin was a fat, perfectly cooked number, easily a 16-oz steak, with about a pound of chunky scalloped potatoes, a good fistful of excellent creamed spinach, and nicely undercooked green and wax beans. A great dish, but way too much food, albeit fairly priced at $23. I'd prefer an $18 dish I could come close to finishing.

My friends got similarly outsized portions of grilled chicken (perfectly done) and a so-called bouillabaisse, a brothless assortment of the expected seafood rather oddly served on a pile of very mediocre risotto.

With three glasses of a terrific Sonoma sauvignon blanc (Matanzas winery), an espresso, and a dessert I don't remember because I didn't touch it, the check came to $105 with tax, pre-tip. Service was friendly and competent.

The consensus was: "Kinda good, but kinda weird for the neighborhood: a decidedly suburban fine-dining experience." I guess you have to let the old fond memories of Ambrosia go, but I can't imagine myself hurrying back here. This place has to be tilting at expense-account types, tourists, and folks who feel swindled if they don't go home with a big doggie bag.

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound