"Foodie" sister's birthday & want to treat to a great meal. Her preference is Italian & she, not I, loves pasta. I am a grilled fish lover. Neither into fancy sauces etc. Was considering Babbo or Grammercy tavern, mainly from what I've read here. By the way I live through your dining experiences on Chowhound. I rarely if ever splurge on a fine dining experience & that's why this is such a big deal with me. I want to make the right choice. Thoughts Please?