I'm looking for a recommendation for my boyfriend and my first anniversary next month. I'm looking for something that is on the quieter side, intimate. Price range is 200-250. I would LOVE a tasting menu including a wine pairing, but I know I could be pushing my luck. He isn't the type for avant-garde cooking; he likes a more classic and perfectly cooked meal. I love a good cheese and charcuterie plate. Italian, French or American would be preferable, but clearly I'm open to suggestions. We had a wonderful Valentine's Day dinner last weekend at Assaggi in Bethesda, if that helps guide your suggestions. Thanks so much everyone!
(PS, and sorry if this sounds shallow... A friend of mine went to Morton's for her anniversary and when they told the staff that, they gave my friend some special stuff, took a commemorative photo and some other swag. I was jealous! I'd love something that we'll get some special treatment for.)