My fiance's birthday is next Friday and he requested Lupa. Of course, all they had available was 5PM or 10:30. I love Lupa but I'm thinking maybe we should go to 50 Carmine instead. I've only seen printed (rave) reviews--anyone have a first-person report? Citysearch's user ratings are pretty awful about the service as well as the food, and while I don't generally go by what they say, the number of complaints made me wonder.