These confections are so dense and chocolaty, one of them could easily satisfy two or three people’s brownie needs. The Wisconsin bakery makes each batch after it is ordered, and ships them via Priority Mail or overnight, so freshness is assured. They come in five varieties, but the Mexican brownies, with a delicate cinnamon-and-spice flavor, are our favorite.

Yellow Cottage Bakery Brownies
Yellow Cottage Bakery, $34 for a dozen brownies

See more articles