Don’t believe a sweet treat featuring slop could be delicious? Think of the secret ingredient as oatmeal instead and you’ll understand just how good these chewy peanut butter chocolate chip cookies (featuring a hefty dose of butter, of course) really are. Use the cookies to make Big Brother Ice Cream Sandwiches and they’re off the charts —and a perfect snack to go with the Big Brother Season 19 premiere on June 28.
This durable and rust-proof aluminum baking sheet conducts heat well, so your cookies (and anything else you make on it) bakes evenly every time.Buy on Amazon ›
To make the ice cream sandwiches: