General Discussion


still not sure about the best type of turkey


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
General Discussion 19

still not sure about the best type of turkey

swimmom | Nov 27, 2011 09:05 AM

Advice invited -- I was disappointed once again by my Bell and Evans fresh turkey. I think I know what I'm doing as far as cooking technique goes, generally following Barbara Kafka's advice, and I always do the same thing and sometimes get great results, so I think the variable is the bird itself. (And I seem to get better birds at other times of the year.) Here are my parameters. I don't have refrigerator capacity to thaw a frozen bird and do not want to thaw one in pots of water; I want a fresh bird. I do not want to get involved in brining, or cooking the turkey outside (although I do have a electric rotisserie for my gas Weber and might try that in reliably good weather -- but not as a plan for November, December holidays in the Northeast). I am not too concerned with price, and would be willing to go to a Kosher butcher if there were valid culinary reasons, but it will add a one hour additional errand to my shopping and it can't be done on Saturday, so it's not always feasible. At the other end of the spectrum, I would even consider a commercial turkey, such as a Butterball, although I've always turned my nose up at them. I realized at the dinner table that I've never actually tried one, and maybe I should. I would also consider Costco, which I love for paper towels but I've never tried their turkey. I just want a reasonably tender bird that tastes like turkey, without days in the fridge or brining. (I am reminded, as I open the Pandora's box of turkey preferences, that the Hawaiian state legislature allowed the humuhumunukunuku's status as "state fish" to expire because they didn't want to revisit such a partisan issue.)

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound