i found some old posts from last summer in the chowhound search but im getting a 404 not found... soooo...
who has thoughts about eating in city island?
old posts talked about some place called the black whale (?).... jimmy's is new but seems like it might be very expensive... johnny's seems like its all fried fish (not a fan).... any other opinions? i'd like to spend a summer evening up there but i won't bother if there's still nothing good enough to make the trip!