Restaurants & Bars

Shelburne Falls - A Bottle of Bread - The GOOD and the BAD


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Restaurants & Bars 5

Shelburne Falls - A Bottle of Bread - The GOOD and the BAD

GaryW | Jun 20, 2005 03:53 PM

My wife, 4 1/2 month old, and myself decided to take a little trip out to Shelburne Falls to get away for a couple of hours on Fathers day.

I did a quick search, came up with this messageboard and cross referenced with a few other sites out there.

Lo and behold.. decided to give A Bottle Of Bread a shot.

Great Place, but something bad did happen that i'll go into as well.

Surprisingly good. Western MA is typically 'culinarily challenged', I hate to say... this is an exception to the rule.

I had the special, Wild and Smoked Salmon Fishcakes. VERY good. Ok, EXCELLENT. My wife had the Miso Salmon dish. Quite good too, but i'm glad I was the one that chose the cakes :) It had an excellent dill sauce, and was accompanied with a very nice selection of greens, rosemary potatoes and beets.

For appetizer we had the marinated goat cheese and beets. Quite good and nice contrast. I also had a cup of chowder. A nice sized bowl for a cup. Not as thick/creamy as typical chowders, but delicious. It had a nice dill/fennel(?) and peppery finish to it.

You should give the local Greenfield People's Pint beer a shot as well. I am a homebrewer and rather picky of my beer. I've never heard of the brewer before, but from the quality of the brew, I expect he has a small operation and doesn't 'overprocess' the product. I'm going to track down the brewery and give them a visit to stock up :) I am craving some more of that brew right now...

We showed up on Sunday at 5pm sharp. This is when they open their doors for dinner. (they serve brunch/lunch as well, which I will come back for sometime). I'm glad we came when we did. The place filled up fast, and for good reason. If you have parties of 4+, they accept reservations apparently. Our waitress was pretty friendly and quick, though she typically could only spare a few seconds due the place being so busy. I'd have rated her GOOD if it wasn't for what came next...


On Monday I checked up on my accounts and did some banking in prep for my vacation to Japan the following week. Lo and behold....

The waitress charged my account MORE than what I signed for on our check. This is a serious black eye on the restaraunt. If my experience there wasn't so good, I would have dissed the place and had quite a negative review here, but its not fair to condemn the owner, Maggie Zaccara, for the actions of a waitress.

Sure, the charge was only $1.60 above what I totalled and signed for, but such action is a breach of contract on her part and really.. any respectable establishment would fire the waiter/waitress and have a zero tolerance policy.

I have always wanted to open my own restaraunt.. i'd love to have a place along the lines of A Bottle of Bread, and I'd never tolerate a waiter or waitress doing such a thing. It would ruin my reputation and in the restaraunt biz, reputation and word of mouth is JUST AS important as the food and atmosphere.

At the restaraunt I said "wow this place is great, we should tell the family about it and get them over here". After I saw the charge, for a moment I hesitated.

**I am going to call the restaraunt this evening after 5pm (when they open) and try to talk to the owner or manager and inform them of this. I'll try to post a response here and let you know the outcome.

Other comments:
While in the area, check out the flower bridge.. a short walk over the river, but nice. Downtown area is small..but a few artsy shops nice to browse or pick something up. Next door is a neat little knitting shop.. get the kid a knit hat. A little icecream shop right across the river is nice on a hot day.


Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound