Restaurants & Bars

Phoenix Irish

Review: Rosie McCaffrey's Irish Pub, Phoenix AZ


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Restaurants & Bars 5

Review: Rosie McCaffrey's Irish Pub, Phoenix AZ

jhenner | Jan 7, 2008 01:11 PM

I try to keep my budget roomy enough to allow me to eat lunch out once a week. My work location at 3rd st and Osborn affords me access to a host of central Phoenix restaurants. Occasionally, I find true gems such as Pane Bianco and Baiz Market.

And then, there’s Rosie McCaffrey’s Irish Pub (Near 7th st and Camelback).

I grew up in Chicago so, I have a relatively decent grasp of what makes good Irish food ( and women). Plus, I watched that episode of Kitchen Nightmare where Gordon Ramsey showed that Irish restaurant how to make his mom’s Shepherd Pie.

Having established my Irish-food-street cred, I feel safe to acknowledge that while spreading Irish slogans and green paint over an establishment creates a campy Irish atmosphere, a stale beer scent reminisce of my college frat house does not. Against my better judgment, I ignored the eau de old Budweiser and sat at the bar.

I ordered a diet coke ($1.95). The bartender served it to me in a tall, wide glass. The best part was that I could have unlimited refills.

While the Rose McCaffrey menu boasts a full sandwich list, I decided to skip over to the dinner entrée section and order a Shepherd’s Pie ($8.75); my theory being, based on my credentials, that an Irish restaurant with a lousy pie is not much of an Irish restaurant.

With the Pie came Potato Soup ($1.25). I added Sour Cream and Onion fries ($3.25) to make sure that I met my starch quota for the day.

The heat was my favorite thing about the soup. I was cold, and wet from the rain. Nice, chunks of potato complimented the rather flat broth, although, the potatoes had a soft, water-logged quality to them. It really wasn’t noticeable and the crumbly effect added interesting textures.

Because I was in my lunch hour, and because the food took too long to arrive, I had the bartender give me my fries in a to-go box. They lacked sufficient sour-cream and onion flavor. I’m thinking the seasoning came from the leavings at the bottom of a bag of sour cream and onion chips.

Reader, have you ever covered left over mashed potatoes with shredded Monterrey Jack cheese? You’ve then eaten Rose McCaffrey’s Shepherd’s Pie.

I spent some time playing “Where’s the Beef”. And, ah, it’s there, in a thin layer beneath the mounds of potato, marinating in a watery broth.

The best flavors in the Shepherd’s Pie came from strips of what appeared to be phyllo dough. Nice, buttery crunch.

While I’m happy I can cross Rosie McCaffrey off my to-try list, I do wish I went to the Noodle Café instead. It was my first choice.

Cherryblossom Noodle Cafe
914 E Camelback Rd Ste 1, Phoenix, AZ 85014

Rosie Mc Caffrey's Irish Pub
906 E Camelback Rd, Phoenix, AZ 85014

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound