I was referred here by someone on TheKnot.com... My husband's grandfather is turning 80 this November and my Father-in-law wants to have the whole family (about 12-15 people) out to dinner to celebrate... Unfortunately, he lives in Chicago... so its up to my husband & I to find a restaurant suitable for this occasion. The grandparents live in Hampton Bays and we'd like to find a nice restaurant near them... Grandpa loves seafood (esp. crab and shrimp dishes) but not everyone else does, so a restaurant with a selection of seafood, but other stuff also, would be really nice! But keep in mind he's a sweet little 80 year old German man, odd and outlandish foods are probably not a good idea. Traditional faire is more his game. Can anyone recommend a restaurant 'Out East' that is nice, but not too stuck up!! :-) Price isn't really a factor... just something nice, cozy, and yummy!! Thanks in Advance!!!