We are looking for a private room for the rehearsal dinner for our upcoming wedding. We would like somewhere downtown, below 42nd street. We would like either new american or italin food. Our choices have been narrowed down to the following, included are some information we have gleamed from the site, as well as our thoughts:
1) Jane [we searched the site and found a few posts that said the restaurant is not that great. Nina W. said she did not think the food is that special.
2) Five points [we searched the site as well and most posts were positive on this place.
3) Pace [we were there last night for their new year's even dinner. even though we liked it and the private dinning room, we thought the place is a little hard to find, for out of town guests]
4) Fiamma [we were there 2 nites ago. We loved the food as well the private room but found the food to be too rich, especially if we were going to have a big wedding dinner the following night]
We would like thoughts on the 4 choices above, especially from people who have dined at the private rooms at jane and five points, as well as other suggestions.
thank you very much, and looking forward to any feed back,