We are looking for a place in the Greenport area or Shelter Isand for a rehearsal dinner in June (around 25 people) We are seafood lovers, inviting a few steak lovers.
We are thinking of the Frisky Oyster (have not been) or Soundview (love the view). We are looking for a restaurant with an emphasis on freshness. Frisky Oyster is a bit above our price range, and Soundview is a bit dingy. We were also thinking of Sweet Tomatoes on Shelter Island but have read bad reviews there.
Can go as far west as Mattituck and as far east as Shelter Island/ Greenport. Any foodie recs?