Restaurants & Bars 22

Maui (Lahaina / Hana) & Big Island (Kona / Volcano Village) recs sought

Frodnesor | May 9, 201202:48 PM

We are planning a trip this summer for about 10 days to Maui and Big Island; we'll probably be spending at least a couple days each in Lahaina or Kapalua and Hana on Maui, and in Kailua-Kona and Volcano Village on Big Island. We're looking primarily for food that's fresh, creative and local (each of those equally valued). High-end and low-end are all welcome, though we are not overly eager to do big-resort dining unless it's genuinely special. On the other hand, I know this may go against the plate-lunch ethos, but we’re less concerned with quantity than quality, though value is always appreciated. Japanese, Vietnamese, Filipino and Thai food, as well as any local specialties, are also welcome.

I know the dilemmas of going to a tourist destination, as a tourist, and hoping for non-touristy dining experiences (we live in Miami Beach), but that's the goal. We're mostly just hoping to avoid the caesar salad / fried calamari / petite filet mignon kinds of uninspired menus.

I've done a good bit of research, here's what is on the list so far, with some specific questions along the way:

LAHAINA / KAPALUA (listed roughly in the order of our interest):

Star Noodle
Merriman's Kapalua
Mala Ocean Tavern
Nagasako Okazu-Ya
Honokowai Okazu-Ya
Aloha Mixed Plate
Plantation House
Pacific'o / I'o

Further afield (KIHEI / KAHALUI / PAIA):

(I’m assuming these places are generally too far to trek for dinner if we’re staying in Lahaina / Kapalua, but may be potential lunch stops during daytime travel):

Monkeypod Kitchen
Eskimo Candy
Mama’s Fish House
A Saigon Cafe
Da Kitchen
Paia Fish Market


(We were planning to spend 2-3 days there; the more I research the more it sounds pretty desolate; two questions: (1) are these roadside places daytime only or are they open for dinner; (2) we will have a kitchen, are there places we can stock up to cook for ourselves?)

Bruddah Hutt
Cafe Romantica
Thai Food by Pranee
Nutcharee’s Authentic Thai Food
Jen’s Thai Food
Clay Oven (Hana Farm - Fri / Sat)
Travaasa Hana - Ka’uiki / Paniolo Lounge


Rapanui Island Cafe
Da Poke Shack
Ba-Le Sandwiches
Okolemaluna Tiki Lounge (I know there’s a recent thread on this)
Island Lava Java
Ceviche Dave’s
Huggo’s on the Rocks

Further afield on Big Island:

(am I right that Waimea / Kamuela is probably too far a commute for dinner from Kailua-Kona?)

Allen’s Table (this seems like exactly the kind of place I’m looking for)
Merriman’s Kamuela
Village Burger
Brown’s Beach House
Monstera Noodles & Sushi
Cafe Pesto
Ken’s House of Pancakes


Thai Thai
Kilauea Lodge
Kiawe Kitchen

So … thoughts on any of the above, places to cross off or add to the list, logistical advice?

Also: recommendations for farmers markets, farms that can be visited, good places to stock up for cooking at home for a night or two, and any local specialties we shouldn’t miss would all be welcome.

Many thanks in advance, and shout out if you're ever coming to South Florida.

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›
Log In or Sign Up to comment

Recommended From CH