Paula Dean and Cat Cora rightfully won that battle because they just seemed to have cleaner more focused desserts with much better aesthetics. Robert Irvine and Tyler Florence's desserts seemed like "a guy's room" - kind of sloppy. Plus they used cranberries in three of their desserts. Anyways, the battle wasn't interesting but did anyone else's jaw drop when Cat Cora gave Robert Irvine a full straddle? Did I really just see that? Are you kidding me?