Just remembered I never followed up with everyone re: our Valentine dinner at Hamilton Inn in Millerton...We were super-psyched to be led to a cozy table in front of the fireplace, but our opinions unfortunately went downhill from there. Service was efficient but quite harried, and let's see if I can remember food details...the lobster cakes were a bit too bready, and the curry flavors overwhelmed any naturally great flavors...we both got the rack of lamb, but the sauce was so sweet, we had to prop up our plates so the sweet sauce could be drained to the side (meat might've been great, you just couldn't taste it!)...dinner ended with the brownie ala mode, but it was more like a spongie cake.
Not fully disappointing (it was Valentine's Day, after all!), but it won't be any place we plan to return to. Too many other great restaurants in the region!