There's a new Middle Eastern place at the corner of Columbus and Broadway (across the street from Alfred Schilling). It looks like a take-out place from the outside, but there are several tables in the back that were nicely dressed up with flowers, art on the walls, etc. The place is open until 3 AM seven days a week!
The menu is *very* extensive, including a dozen appetizers, gyros, felafel, shish kebabs and platters. When I walked in, there were two cooks, the apparent owner and a waitress looking anxious. There were no customers. I expected to order a gyro-type platter, but the platters are quite expensive, over $10. The chalk-board menu was also overwhelming, and the owner encouraged be to order a beef gyro. I complied. Actually, I said I was hoping for lamb and he pointed to the gyro-turner and said, curiously, "Well, there's a little bit of lamb in it, but it's mostly beef."
While the cooks were assembling my gyro, I inquired about where they got their yogurt. "It's homemade," the owner said. He served me up a little dish to try. It was nice and thick and tasted not too fatty--might be what you're looking for, Ruth. I usually eat whole milk Brown Cow or Strauss yogurt and this tasted a little less smooth and more sour to me. Worth a try, though.
Anyway, the owner said everything was homemade, and they use "very high quality meat." I was excited because they have spinach pies and lahmacun (the ground meat pizzas). All platters a served with homemade bread, according to the menu. They also have lentil soup and a soup of the day--which was spiced yogurt today (yum). There's a glass case at the front where all the kebabs and stuff are stored--looking tasty--and there was some very fresh-looking fish. The place looks very promising, but it's surprisingly pricey. I'll have to try a few more things, but it could be a candidate for a Chowhound dinner.
Anyway, my lunch? Well, the meat was flavorful and very, very tender. It came in a grilled lavash with onions, tomatoes (surprisingly good), tahini sauce and parsley. I am not very into wraps, but this is quite good. I would ask, next time, for some tzatziki. I am no authority on gyros so I can't attest to authenticity here.
I'll be back for a spinach pie and lentil soup, maybe tomorrow. I used to live around the corner from a very good, cheap Middle Eastern place in Manhattan and I really miss this kind of food. However, it's not my favorite kind of cuisine, so I don't usually go out of my way for it. I'm glad this place is near my work.
Gyros Grill & More
279 Columbus Ave
(Note that this is not far from Truly Mediterranean. I think this place is really going for a different place, with a full menu, etc.)
by Hana Asbrink | My latest haul. Welcome to Chow...
by Dan Koday | You ever notice how a great marinade can instantly elevate what otherwise would end up as a pretty...
by Eric Silverstein | By Eric Silverstein Chef Eric Silverstein is the founder and owner of The Peached Tortilla in Austin...
Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.