I need help selecting a good delicious seafood shack in Highland, NJ. I'm taking my gf there for Valentine's Day weekend. We're really into authentic and homey places. I see that the options are Original Oyster, Inlet, Bahr's, Off the Hook, Windansea, and the Clam Hut- but I just want to avoid overpriced standard food that's mainly aimed at tourists.
Which ones around the area is still the best in terms of the quality of the food without being overpriced?
We already have a reservation at Bay Avenue Trattoria for another night, but looking for a nice casual spot for the night when we arrive to Highlands via the Ferry.
No car so Atlantic Highlands might not be possible for us.
Thanks so much in advance.
56 Shrewsbury Ave, Highlands, NJ 07732
Clam Hut Restaurant
Atlantic Ave, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716
Off the Hook
1 State Route 36, Highlands, NJ 07732