Restaurants & Bars


To Eat at Eataly or Not


Restaurants & Bars 9

To Eat at Eataly or Not

jennbakes37 | Apr 19, 2011 09:30 AM

Hi all, looking for some opinions and suggestions -
My friend and I are going in May to check out Eataly - I do not get into the city often so I want to make the most of my short day trip - should we eat at Eataly or go somewhere else nearby? My friend is an extremely picky eater so our best bet is italian - is there a place we should not miss? I am hearing the food at Eataly is overpriced and just ok. Or if you did have something delicious there, what was it? How is the pizza?
We do not mind taking a subway to another place to eat but we will only have about 5 hours in the city so we have to cram a lot in. I also love to try cupcakes - I have had all the ones in Grand Central, Crumbs and Melissa's (minis) - I am constantly on the search for "the best." Also, anyone have the gelato at Eataly?

Thanks in advance!

200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound