+
Home Cooking

I discarded too much starter and I panicked. Did I ruin it?

Chandler114 | Apr 10, 201811:13 AM     1

Today is day 5 of my sourdough starter. I'm using King Arthur whole wheat flour (except on day 3 when I used all purpose but I've been using wheat since.)

Last night and this morning it had a very pleasant yeasty taste/Aroma. Although it didn't rise as much as I wanted. Normally, I discard 4 oz of starter and put it in a separate jar to save and add a weighed 4 oz of whole wheat flour and 4 oz of lukewarm water.

After a lot of internet searching and too many different opinions I had a momentary lapse of insanity.
I weighed my starter, was 16 ounces. I took out 8 and put that in my discard jar then I added 4 oz of flour and 4 oz of cold water (because i read cold works better) and stirred it. Then I remembered reading that if you do that that means it's too watery and weak so then I started to panic.

I dumped 2 very full tbsp's in. It was too dry so I measured out a cup of warm water, & poured that in. But before I could use the whole cup it started to look over watery and soupy. So I started to pour it out but then some of my starter went down the drain! I panicked and threw a big tbsp of the discarded starter back in the jar, stirred/tasted it and it just tastes like flour and water. Did I screw up royally and now it's dead? I don't even know what's wrong with me, lol. I'm done researching stuff online it was a nightmare. And now I'm scared I ruined it. How can I fix this?

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

More from Chowhound

13 No-Bake Summer Desserts That Are Stress-Free & Delicious
Recipe Round-Ups

13 No-Bake Summer Desserts That Are Stress-Free & Delicious

by Jen Wheeler | Looking for some easy 4th of July dessert ideas that are ideal for grilling season? Look no further...

11 of Our Most Popular Sides for Summer Grilling & BBQ Season
Recipe Round-Ups

11 of Our Most Popular Sides for Summer Grilling & BBQ Season

by David Watsky | You're well on your way to a great grilling season with our 13 most popular BBQ recipes and even a...

How to Make Wine Pops, the Coolest Summer Treat Around
Recipe Round-Ups

How to Make Wine Pops, the Coolest Summer Treat Around

by Joey Skladany | Ladies and gentlemen, may we present to you the wine pop, a.k.a. your new favorite (and innovative...

This Mixed Berry Pie Couldn’t Be Any Easier to Bake
Food News

This Mixed Berry Pie Couldn’t Be Any Easier to Bake

by Amy Schulman | Best friends Malaka Wilson-Greene and Erica Freeman didn’t expect to land in the baking world. The...

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.