I’m going to be spending a couple of days in Montreal on the way back from eastern Canada. I’d like to identify a couple of dinners, probably with at least one at an upscale fine-dining restaurant (see additional comments below about my research thus far). Cost is not a significant decision factor. Geography isn’t a factor either; I have a car and will be staying in the suburbs, but expect to spend most of the time in downtown/Old Montreal and possibly elsewhere around the city. I’m also open to places that are not super expensive/fancy, so please don’t limit your recommendations to the most high-end places. In a nutshell, my question is this: WHAT ARE THE TOP 2-3 PLACES YOU WOULD RECOMMEND TO SHOW THAT MONTREAL HAS AMAZINGLY DELICIOUS FOOD?
I’m fortunate in enjoying many different kinds of food back home, and my taste is generally pretty wide. But please, no recommendations for steakhouses (too pervasive), no sushi (don’t like it), poutine (yuck), pizza (I live in Chicago), or Montreal-style smoked meat (I’ve had it, don’t hate it but don’t seek it out, and yes I’ve heard of Schwartz’s). FWIW, other places I’ll be dining on this trip before reaching Montreal include the White Barn Inn in Kennebunkport, the Press Gang in Halifax, Lot 30 in Charlottetown, and Restaurant Initiale and/or Restaurant La Cremaillere in Quebec City, as well as a bunch of more casual spots along the way.
In the fine dining category, I’ve been doing searches trying to uncover the best that Montreal has to offer, but it seems like there’s no consensus at all. Every source I look at names different places as the city’s best. I’m a bit surprised, because even in the biggest and best cities for food, you usually hear a handful of names mentioned over and over again as “best of the best”, but that does not appear to be the case with Montreal. These places were listed as tops in four different non-Chowhound sources, with only Toque mentioned in more than one of those sources (and even there, only in two):
L’Eau a la Bouche (EDIT: closed - thanks JohnnyGe)
Le P'tit Plateau
Tapeo Bar à Tapas
Then when I looked at this Chowhound discussion, I see an entirely different group of restaurants recommended, with zero overlap with the previous group:
Another Special Occasion Post.... - www.chow.com/topics/881541
Dominion Square Taverne
3 Petits Bouchons
La Salle A Manger
As for places that aren’t the fancy expensive ones, I haven’t got a clue where to even look. But I’m hopeful that Chowhounds can point me to a few restaurants where the food is absolutely divine despite a more casual atmosphere and a less lofty price point.
I appreciate any recommendations and advice anyone can provide. TIA!