first off I live in the city...
the orchard has its standard menu and is bring your own beer or wine.
aurora has a special 5-course menu which doesn't include alcohol.
I have read great things about both places on the hound and was set to go to Aurora until the snow crushed us yesterday, now I think it may be more of a hastle.
Also, I was wondering if it is better to go to a restaurant on v-day when it is offering a full menu vs. a set menu.